Board info for The Trust Matrix (ALEA)

Board name: The Trust Matrix (ALEA)
Board owned by: Cactus Flower
Date Created: Tue, 26 Feb 08 12:31 PM
Total Posts: 21596
Average Posts per day: 6
Board category: Tech/Communications

Board info, rules and other information:

What's the difference between freedom and anarchy? Only the former contemplates the need for restrictions. Only the former operates on the principle that your freedom only extends as far as it is harmless to others. Virtues compete. My wish for peace and quiet contrasts with your wish to rock it, baby. My wish to build a factory may conflict with the wish of others to create a community park. We've learned the need to strike a balance, draw limits and make hard choices where necessary.

Certain kinds of restriction make freedom not only possible, but also, paradoxically, more extensive. The liberty to buy and sell, own and exchange valuable things is considered an intrinsic principle of freedom. Yet these commercial freedoms are capable of existence only within a framework of practical, ethical and legal exclusion: the need for a key allows me to enter my home and prevents you from doing so; the Eighth Commandment prohibits theft; and the law defines its points of ownership which give me rights and may limit yours. Indeed, the essence of property is the stuff of scarcity, possession, regulation, and security: it cannot exist where there is no restriction and a large society without property necessarily fails. As a practical matter, freedom isn't viable absent the rule of law and a people willing to abide by it.

So in the world of things, while we like to think of freedom as an open-ended universe in which anything is possible, in practice we find it is necessary to regulate many of our activities and our interactions. Freedom is distinct from anarchy precisely because it defines its own limits.

Of course, it is a leap from the world of things, to the world of ideas. Some conditions change. Some of the scarcities of the tangible world do not apply in the vast and empty reaches of cyberspace, except insofar as our imagination has an end. We promote the principle that the realm of ideas should, as far as possible, be free of restriction. Indeed, amongst all social values, this one is probably the one held by many as the most precious, and is enshrined in the First Amendment of the US Constitution.

All the same, in the sphere of ideas, conditions remain: lawyers and economists have long recognised the incentive value of intellectual monopolies to inventors and authors, and have crystallised these into patent and copyright law; we protect certain kinds of secrets - especially those kind of governmental secrets affecting our privacy and our common security; we prohibit the creation of a counterfeit digital currency. The world of speech and information is abridged in all kinds of practical ways which tend to enrich rather than impoverish society. The necessity to constitute encompassing rules precedes all other principles in the same way Magna Carta precedes habeas corpus and the Bill of Rights: only once we have established a society of laws are freedoms conceivable.

In cyberspace, I describe this sort of defined and restrictive construction as 'the trust matrix'. It's a pragmatic architecture designed to offer the network's users security and assurance of their identity, to protect valuable information from loss and misuse, to restrict harmful information from dispersion, to make online commercial transactions authoritative and to make the converged network a healthy place to operate. I believe we are seeing the invisible hand shaping the trust matrix under our noses. It's in the distribution of hardened security frameworks through the cloud and out to the edge of the network. It's in the design of many kinds of equipment and software. It's in the arguments between information producers and users. It's in the dictates of government in a world without frontiers. And it's the topic of this board.

Rule 1: This isn't a dumbocracy. It's a managed conversation space. You are not free to pollute this board with word garbage. The conversation is subject to a set of rules interpreted by a board manager (aka censor). See above for rationale. If you think you have a right to say what you wish in a rule-framed setting, read the introduction again. Freedom from tiresome and obnoxious commentary makes a richer and more friendly space for others. Wild, unsupported assertions waste everyone's time. There's no obligation for me to have to put up with you if you peddle nonsense. On the other hand, I welcome thoughtful posts regardless of whether I agree with them. There's plenty of other space online for you to post if you just wish to vomit letters some place. If you make yourself unmanageable, I will remove you. Before blaming me for it, use a mirror.

Rule 2: This is the necessary corollary of Rule 1. I don't welcome posters with freshly-minted or little-used handles. These are regularly abused by trolls and folks who have been previously banned. Develop a track record somewhere else: a hundred posts is an investment of your time; zero posts isn't. That way I can research your posts to see if you are a poster of substance. Or not. And then you have something to lose, which means perhaps you will bother to post thoughtfully.

Rule 3: Conformity with the law is on you as a poster, not on me as a moderator. AB makes it clear that the site is not responsible for what you post either, so be careful and act legally. For your own sake.

TO ALL OTHERS. Welcome. Nice to have you here.

[only if you are a board moderator]
[only if you are a board moderator]

 21596 post(s)  
Jump to msg. #
ALEA | Board info. Prev 30 | Home | Next 30 
  Post new message | Refresh List | Threaded View | Last 15 posts | Boardmark this board
 Msg. #  Subject Posted by     Date   
26898 Internal GOP Poll: Pelosi Beats Trump in a Head-to-Head Matchup clo  21 Sep 2018  
3:33 PM
26897 Voters say 2-to-1 the tax law benefits rich over middle class clo  21 Sep 2018  
3:30 PM
26896 Ed Whelan, Judge Kavanaugh’s Defender, Just Committed Defamation clo  21 Sep 2018  
2:34 PM
26895 We all knew Trump couldn't resist.... clo  21 Sep 2018  
1:12 PM
26894 Franklin Graham Cactus Flower  21 Sep 2018  
12:24 PM
26893 Novel idea for GOP Cactus Flower  21 Sep 2018  
11:34 AM
26892 Re: Kavanaugh defence already caught in a possible lie over Ford Cactus Flower  21 Sep 2018  
11:22 AM
26891 Re: Man Who Strangled and Masturbated on Woman Gets No Jail Time Cactus Flower  21 Sep 2018  
11:17 AM
26890 Re: Kavanaugh defence already caught in a possible lie over Ford clo  21 Sep 2018  
10:51 AM
26889 Man Who Strangled and Masturbated on Woman Gets No Jail Time clo  21 Sep 2018  
10:47 AM
26888 Kavanaugh defence already caught in a possible lie over Ford Cactus Flower  21 Sep 2018  
9:17 AM
26887 BREAKING: More Americans oppose Kavanaugh confirmation than support it, clo  20 Sep 2018  
8:26 PM
26886 Spanish foreign minister claims Trump told him to build wall across the Sahara desert to stop migrants clo  20 Sep 2018  
7:05 PM
26885 Christine Blasey Ford, reopened discussions for testifying publicly before the Senate. clo  20 Sep 2018  
5:55 PM
26884 What Kavanaugh deserves — and what we deserve from him clo  20 Sep 2018  
5:26 PM
26883 If they take Hillary out of the Texas text books... clo  20 Sep 2018  
4:44 PM
26882 New sign for the midterm clo  20 Sep 2018  
3:55 PM
26881 Brett Kavanaugh’s unlikely story about Democrats’ stolen documents clo  20 Sep 2018  
3:31 PM
26880 csl, Let me know why you described Dr Ford as a fanatical Trump hater Cactus Flower  20 Sep 2018  
2:24 PM
26878 Re: Exactly! Cactus Flower  20 Sep 2018  
11:47 AM
26877 Black Candidate Campaigning in WI Has Police Called on Her clo  20 Sep 2018  
11:05 AM
26876 Ex Chicago Cop Linked to Torture of 100+ Suspects Dies clo  20 Sep 2018  
10:58 AM
26875 Re: Exactly! clo  20 Sep 2018  
10:12 AM
26874 Kavanaugh Resume Cactus Flower  20 Sep 2018  
9:03 AM
26873 Re: Exactly! Cactus Flower  20 Sep 2018  
8:54 AM
26872 Exactly! clo  20 Sep 2018  
7:38 AM
26871 No answer from csl re his apparently false claim that she is an anti-Trump activist Cactus Flower  19 Sep 2018  
7:48 PM
26870 Re: BREAKING: Kavanaugh accuser's schoolmate says she recalls hearing of alleged sex assault Cactus Flower  19 Sep 2018  
7:35 PM
26869 BREAKING: Kavanaugh accuser's schoolmate says she recalls hearing of alleged sex assault clo  19 Sep 2018  
6:23 PM
26868 Trump slams Sessions; "I don't have an attorney general." clo  19 Sep 2018  
12:44 PM
   Post new message | View by thread | Last 15 posts | You are at board ALEA
 21596 post(s)  
Jump to msg. #
ALEA | Board info. Prev 30 | Home | Next 30