Replies to Msg. #981240
.
 Msg. #  Subject Posted by    Board    Date   
14797 Re-submit the Constitution ?
   Zim: If the Republican Governors was to call for a Constitutional Co...
Zimbler0   POPE IV   19 Nov 2016
1:53 AM
14796 Re: Republicans Now Control Record Number of State Chambers...
   Decomposed> So, why is it that this question was routed to me? Did I s...
Zimbler0   POPE IV   19 Nov 2016
1:47 AM
14770 Re: Republicans Now Control Record Number of State Chambers...
   decomp ...if Hillary had won, I expected to see a supreme court decis...
ribit   POPE IV   18 Nov 2016
7:15 PM

The above list shows replies to the following message:

Re: Republicans Now Control Record Number of State Chambers...

By: Decomposed in POPE IV
Fri, 18 Nov 16 11:29 AM
Msg. 14731 of 47202
(This msg. is a reply to 14705 by Zimbler0)
Jump to msg. #  

Zimbler? 

re: "Would all the demorats efforts to chip away at the Constitution be erased?"

That would be a good first case for the new Supreme Court to decide. My guess would be no, since the Court would otherwise have an overwhelming number of challenged decisions to make on Day One of the "new" United States. Rather than do that, I think the country would opt to continue with the laws and decisions as they had previously been.

Additionally, if the existing Constitution were offered up, it would mean by definition that the Constitutional Convention had decided not to change anything.

If, however, a single word of the Constitution were changed, then yes, we'd be starting from scratch with a Constitution requiring literal interpretation. All the existing "chips" (as you described them) would have to be re-thought. Words have consequences upon which houses of cards are often built. Change ANYTHING, and the entire structure of court-rulings and interpretations would need new consideration.

So, why is it that this question was routed to me? Did I say something that got you to wondering? 




Avatar

Gold is $1,581/oz today. When it hits $2,000, it will be up 26.5%. Let's see how long that takes. - De 3/11/2013 - ANSWER: 7 Years, 5 Months