Replies to Msg. #767501
.
 Msg. #  Subject Posted by    Board    Date   
11563 Re: Opportunities for Obama
   "I believe engagement strengthens the hand of the moderates. Isola...
clo   ALEA   09 Nov 2012
3:30 AM
11556 Re: Opportunities for Obama
   Dig, You cannot begin to compare Iran to the old Soviet Union. For...
joe-taylor   ALEA   09 Nov 2012
12:13 AM

The above list shows replies to the following message:

Re: Opportunities for Obama

By: DigSpace in ALEA
Thu, 08 Nov 12 11:28 PM
Msg. 11554 of 54959
(This msg. is a reply to 11553 by joe-taylor)
Jump to msg. #  

JT,

yes on who is in charge. And, generally over the last 33 years, the moderates gain influence, policies relax, and then the hammer comes down as an excuse of an external threat and so on legitimizes a swing back to the fundoright.

I think there is more value to just being at a table than you are giving credit to. The whole respect/legitimacy thing.

There was a big argument for confrontation with the USSR, and another argument that if we just stay out of war, they will implode. Yes, there was the USbuildup, but it was the engagement that settled matters down (in this case getting Reagan to chill out a touch). Then is was just a matter of staying out of a fight.

The same internals are at work in Iran. Iran internally wants to moderate. I believe engagement strengthens the hand of the moderates. Isolation strengthens the hand of the extremists.