Replies to Msg. #759129
.
 Msg. #  Subject Posted by    Board    Date   
10760 Re: Presidents list
   hi csl, one extra point. i think you would be less easy-going about...
Cactus Flower   ALEA   11 Oct 2012
5:52 PM
10759 Re: Presidents list
   The US Constitution compromise on slavery was like the last debt compr...
DigSpace   ALEA   11 Oct 2012
5:44 PM
10757 Re: Presidents list
   Ceceeding was not about tarrifs! The minute that the southern states...
joe-taylor   ALEA   11 Oct 2012
4:43 PM
10754 Re: Presidents list
   Hi csl, i guess we have a different idea of western countries. oddl...
Cactus Flower   ALEA   11 Oct 2012
8:14 AM

The above list shows replies to the following message:

Re: Presidents list

By: xcslewis in ALEA
Thu, 11 Oct 12 7:27 AM
Msg. 10753 of 54959
(This msg. is a reply to 10749 by Cactus Flower)
Jump to msg. #  

The American revolution was a war to separate the colonies from England so the war between the states would be the second American war of sucession.

I believe emancipation occured in Brazil and Puerto Rico in the 1870' and Cuba in the 1880's.

I believe the U S constitution reached a compromise only on the representation issue relating to the slave population. The issue of slavery itself was left to the states rather that the federal government.

I believe the sucession was about tariffs. The agricultural South either paid a tariff for imported manufactured goods or higher prices to Northern manufacturers. Effectively the Southern states were paying the cost of federal projects. Lincoln was a Whig, similar to today's crony capitalists, and wanted to greatly expand government financed projects.

Rather than humanitarian intent often ascribed to them many northerners simply wanted new states to be "white" only.

I believe had suceeding states been allowed to suceed slavery would have died a natural death for moral and economic reasons. In addition slaves escaping to the North would have no longer enforced the fugitive slave laws. Once slavery had ended the suceeding states very likely would have rejoined knowing the were free to leave as was tje original intent when the union began.